Thursday, November 17, 2011

LAD #14 Lincoln's First Inaugural Address


Summary of Lincoln's First Inaugural Address:

Lincoln states that he does not believe in discussing matters that are not of pressing concern to the nation in his public address, and he immediately starts discussing the issue of slavery. He claims that it is not his intention to interfere with Southern slavery; that it is a right of the states which he has no right to interfere in, and that no States within the Union will be favored in regards to Constitutional protection over any others. Further, he claims that the return of fugitive slaves is written in the original Constitution, and thus that the Fugitive Slave law will be enforced. He pleads for States to abide by existing laws instead of reputing them in the hope that they will be examined and found unconstitutional.

Further, Lincoln is aware that he is entering the Presidency at a difficult time, with the threat if disunion perpetually growing.  However, he believes that disunion by any one state from the union undermines the Constitution and the laws of the Union, and it is Lincoln's intention to execute the established laws to the best degree possible, as is his assigned job for his post. Ultimately though, it is the peoples' right to decide the fate of the country. Furthermore, he does not intend to use force against any portion of the nation.

Lincoln claims that never have Constitutional rights been openly denied to people of America. Also, if the minority secedes from the majority if the States, as they threaten to do, who is to say that the resulting body will not continually secede from the greater body every time the minority does not get its way? The idea of secession is essentially anarchy. In addition, a secession may separate the government of the United States and the independent body, but it is impossible for the independent body to physically move away from the mainland United States.

Although he does not advocate it, the people have the right to amend the Constitution. He even acknowledges that they have the right to revolutionarily overthrow the government. However, he generates his power from the people, and it is his task to uphold the present government. Finally, he encourages the people to carefully of their decisions, and it is ultimately in their hands whether or not to go to civil war. And Lincoln promises that he will preserve, protect, and defend the nation.

Monday, November 14, 2011

LAD #13 Calhoun's Speech on Clay's Compromise Measures


Summary of John Calhoun's Speech on Clay's Compromise of 1850, in regards to slavery in Texas:

(Speech was read by another senator, as Calhoun was too ill to read it himself. The speech was read on March 4, 1850, and Calhoun passed away March 31, that same month.)

Calhoun recognized that the unity of the Union was threatened. He goes on to discuss the issues that were endangering the Union.

The Southern States were originally agitated by the slavery question, and their discontent has grown, despite the meager calming influence of widespread political parties. The overpowering force of the North in government has overshadowed the South, which was caused by the North's greater number of States and greater population. And the growth in States in the North showed no signs of letting up. Thus, the North will gain a much larger representation in the Senate over the South.

Also, the South claims that their States have been restricted in land claims (in the Northern attempts to receive Texas) and have received an undue amount of taxation, while the North gained territory and most of the benefits of taxes. Similarly, the South is a major exporter of goods, and thus was hard hit by the tariffs, and it has few factories, and thus did not receive the benefits of the duties taxes.

The slavery question is particularly perplexing, and as the North pushes so ardently for abolition, Calhoun believes abolition or secession are the only options available for the South. To prevent the dissolution of the nation's unity, Calhoun pleads to appease the demands of the Southern States, claiming that appeasing them will remove the source of agitation that initiated the Southern discontent. However, he claims that only the stronger power, the North, can institute a Constitutional amendment to re-establish the equilibrium between the North and the South. He then rawly challenges the Senators to make their choice, reducing the issue to either submitting to Calhoun's idea of Northern support or to forcing the Southern secession. He even proclaims that California will be a test, and if it is admitted under Northern conditions, the South will interpret the situation as though the North were deliberately crushing the South for ambitions of power and aggrandizement.

Sunday, November 13, 2011

LAD #12 President Polk's War Message


Summary of President James K. Polk's War Message, 1846:

An America envoy, John Slidell, was sent to Mexico to reestablish friendly relations between the nations and to solidify international boundaries, but he was rejected by their government. Furthermore, Mexico has invaded American territory and shed American blood.

Mr. Slidell had been assured he would be accepted by the Mexican government under General Herrera, which was at the time tottering. When he arrived, a popular revolutionary party forced the government to refuse Mr. Slidell. Approximately a month later, General Herrera surrendered the Presidency to General Paredas; a revolution conducted solely by the military.

Mr. Slidell attempted to become an envoy to the new, militaristic Mexican government, but was refused. Thus, the Mexican government refused negotiation with American for no sufficient reason, and had made no propositions of its own to remedy the existing border and citizen issues in Texas.

An American military force had previously been assembled between the Nueces and the Del Norte Rivers to meet a potential Mexican invasion attempt, which was threatened after Texas's appeal and resulting annexation into the U.S.

American generals were instructed to move troops but without aggressive action towards Mexico, on the Mexican side of the Del Norte River. However, Mexican General Ampudia ordered the Americans to retreat, and after a month without their cooperation, he announced that he considered hostilities to have commenced. A small group of American soldiers were attacked while scouting the Mexican troops, and some were killed while the rest were forced to surrender.

Polk proposes that America is called to fight Mexico as a result of Mexico's wrongs against American citizens over the past years, that trade with Mexico long ago stopped being beneficial, and that America has long attempted unsuccessful peaceful negotiations. Furthermore, after Mexico has declared war on the U.S., invaded American territory, and killed American citizens, the conflict would be a vindication of American honor, rights, and interests.

Friday, November 11, 2011

LAD #11 Seneca Falls Decleration


Summary of the Seneca Falls Declaration of Sentiments and Resolutions, written by Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan b. Anthony, and M.J. Gage, July 19, 1848:

There are two portions in the Seneca Falls Declaration, the first being the Declaration of Sentiments. This first portion was structured very similarly to the American Declaration of Independence. It copies the wording the the Declaration of Independence's intro and simply adds in phrases like "...all men and women are created equal...". This method both draws attention to the document, invokes the patriotism of the heroic Declaration of Independence, and takes a stab at the hypocritical irony of the glorified male struggle for independence and the suppression of women under the law. It further copies the Declaration of Independence by citing a list of grievances, most valid, some exaggerated, including such points as the historical lack of women's right to vote; the lack of women's civil rights, particularly for married women; her inability to participate in law, medicine, the church, or the government; her inability to earn a male's wages; the altered codes of moral behavior between men and women; and a woman's inability to receive a complete education at college. Finally, the authors acknowledge that they will be ridiculed, but that they will continue to petition for their rights and attempt to hold further conventions.

The second portion lists the resolutions of the women, which proclaim their views on the issues mentioned in their grievances and proclaim what ought to be accomplished. For example, the women resolve that it is their duty to secure their "sacred right to the elective franchise". They close by mentioning it is the right and duty of both men and women to promote "...every righteous cause by every righteous means..." and thus that the rights of women ought to be proclaimed.

Sunday, October 30, 2011

LAD #10 The Monroe Doctrine

Summary of the Monroe Doctrine, 1823:

In President Monroe's seventh inaugural address to Congress in 1823, Monroe mentions negotiations with Russia and Britain, and arising from the discussions, Monroe proposes that "the occasion has been judged proper for asserting, as a principle in which the rights and interests of the United States are involved, that the American continents...are henceforth not to be considered as subjects for future colonization by any European powers..."

Monroe claims that the United States is unwilling to take part in any European wars, and that it only will fight in defense of American rights or a menace to public safety. However, America is intricately tied the other nations/colonies of the American continent, and that any attempt to colonize the newly-independant nations of the Americas will be viewed as a threat to the peace and safety of the United States. However, the United States will not interfere with current colonies, it only will protect the freedom of those nations that the U.S. officially recognizes as independent.

The U.S. foreign policy in regards to European nations remains unaffected; refrain from interfering in their internal affairs and to maintain friendly relations with them.

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

LAD #9 Jefferson's Inaugural Address


Summary of Thomas Jefferson's First Inaugural Address:

1st Paragraph- Jefferson appreciates his election to the Presidency, but is humbled by the enormous undertaking.

2nd Paragraph- Jefferson encourages Americans to unite for the common good under the freedoms granted by the Constitution; he assures them that the majority will prevail but will preserve the rights and  equality of the minorities; and he asserts that they are all a united people under a strong government, free from the trials and errors and bloodshed of the governmental mishaps of the Old World.

3rd Paragraph- Jefferson encourages the Americas to look to the future, reminds Americans of the bountiful blessings of their country, including available land, industry, and beliefs in morality, and especially a good government that protects the rights of the people.

4th Paragraph- Jefferson lists the essential principles of the Constitution:

  • Equal justice to men
  • Support of State Governments
  • Preservation of the Central Government
  • The Right of Election
  • Absolute Acquiescence in Majority Decisions
  • Well-disciplined Militia
  • Civil Authority over Military Authority
  • Public Economy
  • Payment of Debts
  • Encouragement of Agriculture and Commerce
  • Freedom of Religion, of the Press, and of Person
4th Paragraph- Jefferson understands that he will not be a perfect President, and asks that the public to forgive him for any mistakes he is bound to make, but he will do all the good in his power for the good of his fellow Americans.

5th Paragraph- Jefferson is prepared to work for the country, and invokes "that Infinite Power" to lead his councils to "what is best".

Sunday, October 9, 2011

Columbus Blog #8


Is Christopher Columbus a hero or a villain?

Christopher Columbus can neither be defined solely as a hero or as a villain. He is a complex figure, created by the culture and ethics of the early European Renaissance, and there is no denying his seamanship. If one were to classify Columbus as either a hero or a villain, he would be both. However, he was perhaps more a villain because of his cruel treatment of the Natives he encountered in the "New World".

Columbus is arguably the instigator of the first genocide in the Western hemisphere. In fact, when Columbus first landed in the Bahama Islands in 1492, some of the first comments he made reflected what we now perceive with moral repugnance. He comments on the fine build and naivety of the Native Arawak people, and then he adds, "They would make fine servants...With fifty men we could subjugate them all and make them do whatever we want." And Columbus did just that- despite the excessive generosity of the Natives, Columbus and his crew took some of them captive to guide the Spaniards to gold.  After sailing to Hispaniola, Columbus took more Native prisoners, killing several when they refused his demands. As Columbus sailed back to Spain with his human cargo, the Natives started to die.
Columbus soon returned with a larger expedition, pursuing slaves and gold. When excessive amounts of slaves started dying en route, he turned to forcing Native children to collect gold for him. When the children did not produce the precious metal, the Spaniards would mutilate them, cutting off their hands and letting them bleed to death. Native resistance became impossible due to Spanish weapons, and soon Natives started committing suicide. Natives who didn't were forced to work to death on encomiendas. By 1515, only about 23 years after Columbus first landed in the New World, only about fifty thousand of an original two-hundred and fifty thousand Natives were alive.

However, it is important to remember that Christopher Columbus was (most likely) not a particularly sadistic man. During this time period, slavery was a common practice, and Columbus can not be considered a villain for following the common beliefs of the day. It would not be abolished in Spain and in most of Europe until the early nineteenth century. Columbus certainly cannot be vilified for pursuing gold and wealth for his country, considering that the Gulf War and even arguably the current war in the Middle East is motivated by oil, the "new gold". It is really Columbus's inhumane treatments of the Natives that incriminates him, but again, Americans would continue to treat Native Americans inhumanely for hundreds of years to come. Furthermore, Columbus was brave enough and enterprising enough to lead an expedition that spearheaded the future of the modern world.

Thus, Columbus was both a hero and a villain, although his incredibly cruel actions towards Natives arguably incited the first modern genocide. Thus, Columbus is considered a villain to a greater extant than he would be considered a hero.